Home arrow Create arrow Seeking Rejection

Seeking Rejection

Seeking Rejection
Written by John   
Saturday, 01 March 2008

Late last year I discovered a contest set up by Weiden + Kennedy .  They were seeking people .  People to work at W+K.  Applicants were asked to submit a 20 page or less 11"x19" PDF.  No other criteria were specified although companion emails hinted at telling a story.

I am not a graphic artist, but I can envision ideas, even if I cannot create them.  My work in PowerPoint has taught me that I you can create professional looking results with stock photography and some photoshop skills.

I created an entry for the contest.  I spent a *lot* of time on it.  It was over the holiday period which afforded a little more time than typically available.

I love coming up with ideas.  I could have come up with 100's of ideas for this contest.  I actually would have preferred more criteria for the contest as I believe that would have showcased my creative thinking skills much more.

What should I submit?  A 20-page portfolio?  That seemed way too lazy.  Not only that, but I didn't have a portfolio.  What about a single page?  A single page ad perhaps?  That was scary.  Putting all of your eggs in one basket.  I could have done something in between, but I felt  that made less of a statement.

I was torn between creating a PDF about me and creating a PDF showing what I was capable of.  I ended up doing a mixture.  I was personal and vulnerable.  I was honest and open.  I have shown some friends and received an awesome response.  I went back to the PDF after a month or so and was very pleased with what I created.  I am most proud of one single page.  It shows my love of music.

  Music

 

I often wonder if people notice that the letters at the beginning of the lines correspond to the letters e,g,b,d,f?

I received a sticker from W+K recently indicating I was not one of the 40 selected to go on to the next stage.  Part of me is relieved.  A bigger part of me is dissapointed.  It would have been a grand adventure.   Even though I was ultimately rejected, I am glad for the experience.  My only complaint is that I got no feedback on my subsmission.

As an aside, the domain seekingrejection.com is available.  Maybe someone with lots of time on their hands can create a showcase site for W+K Seeking rejects?





Reddit!Del.icio.us!Facebook!Slashdot!Netscape!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Furl!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites! title=
Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
Amazing write-up
Razzak Mohammed (Unregistered) 2009-04-11 15:35:43

Thought-provoking article !
I have a few similar experiences where I felt I should have received feedback, even though I was rejected. Guess people don't realise the time and effort spent on something creative which they actually wanted. Welcome, join the gang !

P.S. Tried hard, but could not fathom "I often wonder if people notice that the letters at the beginning of the lines correspond to the letters e,g,b,d,f? "

Regards,

Razzak
E G B D F
John (Unregistered) 2009-04-11 21:54:35

The letters correspond to the musical notes.
http://ellenkimball.blogspot.c
Ellen Kimball (Unregistered) 2009-04-27 19:28:40

John, I liked your submission. The only problem with your writing was that you might have explained the E,G,B,D,F. I've been briefly trained in piano, but I know immediately what you were trying to do.

Perhaps they were looking for some of your former work. I don't think they have any clients involved in music, do they? I could be wrong about that, but it might have been good to understand their client list at this time.

Also, you have misspelled the word "disappointed" in your post!

Forgive me, I've been writing copy for decades (McCann-Erickson, Norman, Craig & Kummel, BBDO, and tons of temporary jobs, all in Miami or NYC). Spelling errors just jump out at me.

Don't feel badly. I was interviewed by Weiden + Kennedy about ten years ago. I got to the fourth interview, all with women, and was suddenly rejected. I think it was my age, but it didn't really matter.

I've worked for women before and can't remember one that actually helped advance my career. This goes back to the 1950s. Since I was one of the first women on-air in radio and TV, most people who hired me were men, of course.

Hope you connect with a position soon.

Cordially,

Ellen Kimball
Twitter me! @Radio_Lady
Usually, this is the spot for
Ellen Kimball (Unregistered) 2009-04-27 19:32:02

Should you be interested, go to:

http://ellenkimball.blogspot.com

Woman, wife, mother, stepmother, grandmother, stepgrandmother -- celebrating 70 years next month.

I'm originally from Pittsburgh, PA, but lived in Miami, Florida, New York City, Boston, MA and now Portland, OREGON.
Write comment
Name:
Title:
Security Image

Powered by JoomlaCommentCopyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved.Homepage: http://cavo.co.nr/

 
< Prev   Next >